I want to share my biggest concern that impacts the conduct of legitimate online usage. My job is helping companies be more successful applying technology to their business. Since I work with so many clients I get to see so many of the issues with the modern Net up close and personal. The issue
I want to address is unsolicited commercial email (or Spam), and offer MY SOLUTION. You may have a different view and I encourage you to post it here to share with others.
Problem: SPAM, or unsolicited commercial email (UCE). The cost of sending email is so minimal there is little to prevent abuse. As an ISP I have to maintain both virus filters and spam filters to prevent my clients email boxes from being jammed full of crud. These filters in turn have to be set so aggressively that periodically a legitimate message gets rejected. For example, last month I found messages from my travel agent, my financial advisor and a physician in my junk folder because they match a pattern similar to spam.
The other issue I have is the vast amounts of pornographic UCE messages. Fortunately, most get caught by the filters, but I was recently helping one of my kids with their email and when we dropped into their junk folder it was like we had unwittingly entered a red light district. The CAN-SPAM Act of 2003 legislated that pornographic UCE had to comply with certain standards, which have largely been ignored. I don't like the idea that my children or I are unwittingly confronted with pornography in the confines of our own home.
My Solution: Eliminate anonymity online. The only reason people perform this obnoxious behavior is because there are no consequences. Sites like Paypal, and Ebay require you to verify who you are with credit cards and enforce good conduct through feedback from other users. Some may argue this is giving up their right to privacy, but the fact is every time you go online, your IP address is available (just like your cell phone location can be picked up through towers even if you aren't making a call), so anyone who wants to can easily track you down. I would gladly exchange a limited amount of privacy if it would clean up the unruly nature of the Net.
In fact, the European Union is proposing to make it a crime to falsify information when you open an email account (see the following article), thus eliminating a certain degree of privacy. Their primary concern is fighting terror and crime. For those who do not want to give up their personal information, creating an unmanaged Net will let them surf porn and exchange viruses in privacy.
In summary, I am concerned that the Internet is rapidly becoming such a problematic arena that the energy we put into thwarting the bad apples is cutting into our bottom line. Unsolicited email is rapidly undermining our ability to conduct business through this vital channel. There simply is little or no reason for spammers to stop because of the anonymity of the Net. Unless we can encourage people to give up some of their personal information in order to validate who they are the problem will only get worse and all the Spam filters in the word won't stop the avalanche.